Book Reviews · Reading

Book Review: The Lord of the Rings (#100)

Book: The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien

#100 on the Telegraph’s 100 novels everyone should read.

Grade: A

What is it about?

I don’t think The Lord of the Rings needs any introductions. It is an epic tale where nine companions set out to save Middle Earth from falling into complete darkness by destroying the one ring that the Dark Lord needs so he can achieve complete domination. The story follows nine fellows of the ring: Gandalf (wizard), Aragorn (man), Boromir (man), Legolas (elf), Gimli (dwarf), Peregrin a.k.a. Pippin (hobbit), Meriadoc a.k.a. Merry (hobbit), Sam (hobbit), and Frodo (hobbit) on their quest to help the ring bearer annihilate the Lord of the Ring by destroying the ring itself.


Before I say anything about the book, I have to say this: I don’t like fantasy. I steer away from anything too whimsical, be it novel or movie. I can’t really understand anything that is too out there. That being said, I loved loved loved this book.

I don’t know where to start. Tolkien is a genius. He created an entire world that is so believable, even a fantasy-hater believed it. Each race and each individual has their own different dimensions and are beautifully crafted. The different languages, wonderfully named cities so intricately described that the reader feels they are walking there with them.

Let me add some more praise to Tolkien. He achieved with just letters on white paper, what Hollywood could not achieve with all its sound effects, visual effects, and handsomely paid actors. I hated the movie (only saw part one and two, as no one can persuade me to watch the third). I remember vividly in part 2 saying: Oh now they brought in walking talking trees? Come on! Reading the book I said: how I would love to meet an Ent! And maybe drink from their draught so my post baby hair could stop falling.


I was scared when the Hobbits went to the Prancing Pony, I got goose bumps when Aragorn came on the black ships, and I couldn’t put the book down filled with suspense when Frodo and Sam were on Mount Doom. Now, watching the movies again with my husband, I keep on saying: no no noo! It shouldn’t be this way! Please stop messing with the plot Mr. Producer. Tolkien is considered a genius for a reason. And that is exactly why the book is much better than the movie.

I can’t really fault this book with anything. So I went to Google to see what other people saw that I couldn’t. I found two main schools of thought: racism and feminism. Now I am no Tolkien expert, I just read one book of his and know nothing of the fantasy genre or its history, but here are my thoughts regarding these two criticisms.

  1. Racism:I didn’t find the Lord of the Rings to be racist. Good and evil have forever been cast as black vs. white and darkness vs. light. This depiction was not about ‘race’ at all but about symbolism in the fight between good and evil. In my opinion, the Lord of the Rings is as racist as the yin yang.Yin_and_Yang.svg.png


    The only relationship in the book that I was a bit bothered with was Frodo and Sam’s relationship, as Frodo was his Master. But, as they are both from the same race and color, this can be called “master – ism” if that’s a word or superiorism, not racism.

  2. Feminism:

    Feminist critics point out the lack of female characters in the Lord of the Rings. And if they were present, they had feminine roles. Now I am a female and don’t feel at all insulted by Tolkien. I was actually insulted by George Elliot’s Middlemarch as the females there all had no brains what so ever and were only worried about how frilly their collars were. (Don’t get me started with that book! You can read its review here). Eowyn killed the head of the nazguls, the wring wraiths, whom all were afraid of, what ‘feminine role’ is that? True, there are much fewer females than males in this story, but I will take that over mindless, frill-seeking, immature ones any day.


And there you have it. My thoughts on an epic fantasy tale which to my great surprise, I loved! Next book: To Kill a Mockingbird. Harper Lee, you have one hard act to follow.

12 thoughts on “Book Review: The Lord of the Rings (#100)

  1. I love this book and I like the movie. Thankful to it actually as I wouldn’t have been interested to read it if not for the fact that I’ve seen the 1st film and was so amazed 😊. And people who says LotR is racist and anti-feminist are doing so just because they are maybe jealous or can’t comprehend Tolkien’s genius or what a brilliant piece of art the book is.


    1. Thank you 4 ur comment 🙂 before reading the book, i disliked fantasy so much. This included LOTR, star wars, and anything like that. I was so reluctant to pick up the book and actually start reading. I am so thankful for the telegraph list for making me read it. Now i will think twice before judging if i will like the book before i read it or no.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your reply. Lord of the Rings is amazing! You wont regret picking it up. I read to kill a Mockingbird in highschool, but being a loooong time ago, its worth a reread. 👍 hope u enjoy the books


  2. Just giving a different perspective on Yin and Yang: This Taoist symbol is not as racist as you think! It just says some things are more Yin than Yang and vice versa. And if you notice again, the Yin part (Black) contains some Yang (White dot) and the Yang part contains some Yin. So they are kind of accommodating 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  3. LOL. I also realised my mistake. You did mention LOTR is not racist as many people believe it to be! I really don’t understand one thing that why people get mad over characters described, for, example as “having dark skin” or “small slanty eyes” . Come on, those are characters in an ENTIRELY fictional and fantasy setting and maybe the author just takes inspiration from people around the world.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Exactly! And i dont see anything wrong with them .. our differences is what makes us unique and we should be proud of them. People are calling for dolls to be made with different features .. dunno why they call it racist when it comes to characters in books 🤔

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I call that ‘modern day racism’ where the mere fact abut talking about different races is considered making a ‘racist remark’. And then I have to tell people that you’re racist when you despise a group of people for their race; and not when you just merely talk about them.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s